Starling Proofing the Suet

Suet Feeders
Suet Feeders Protected with Plastic

Most of the year, I don’t get European Starlings in the yard, but winter snows bring all kinds of birds to the feeders. Starlings are actually kind of pretty if you take the time to look at them closely . . . but they can be a real pain when they latch onto the suet feeders. In my experience, most birds will sit on or next to a suet feeder and eat for a minute or even up to five. Starlings will settle on top of a suet cage and eat and eat and eat until the suet is gone. They won’t move, except maybe for a squirrel, so the other birds get nothing.

One third of a Block (Slightly Nibbled) of Suet in a Suet Cage Feeder
One third of a Block of Suet (a Bit Nibbled) in a Suet Cage Feeder

I’ve got a couple of strategies for deterring starlings from the suet. The first, I discovered last winter by accident. I noticed that when there is only an inch or two of suet left in the bottom of a suet cage that dangles by a chain, Starlings have more trouble settling in to eat it all. They seem to like to sit on top rather than cling and if they do cling, they don’t really want to hang upside down. They can still get to it but because they can’t really settle in and get comfortable, they don’t sit there nearly as long.

Cutting a Suet Block into Thirds
Cutting a Suet Block into Thirds

So I started cutting my purchased suet blocks into narrow thirds and only putting a third into the bottom of the dangling cage at a time. It’s not a complete fix, but I found it helped a lot.

Peeling Open a Commercial Suet Block and Discarding Only the Top Liner
Peeling Open a Commercial Suet Block and Discarding Only the Top Liner

I have since read another solution which is to peel off the thin plastic cover on purchased suet blocks but leave the slightly thicker plastic bottom and sides of the package. Then put the whole thing in the suet cage feeder.

Dangling Plastic Protected Suet Cage Feeder
Dangling Plastic Protected Suet Cage Feeder

If you then hang the suet cage on its side so that the exposed side faces down, starlings have a harder time getting to the suet. More agile birds like Downy Woodpeckers, wrens, titmouses, etc. can still eat fine. (I suspect they prefer the easier to eat suet cage mounted right up against a tree trunk, but if they can’t access it because of a greedy starling, that seems a bit moot.) There are starlings that can figure this out, but again, they can’t stay on for long periods of time so they are less likely to dominate the suet.

Wren On Suet
Wren On a Large Suet Cage Feeder

I offer suet all year long and have kept up the plastic layer in most of my suet feeders even when there are no starlings bothering them. In the warmer months, I’ve noticed that suet left out in the elements will get a layer of unappetizing green or black mold over the surface after a few consecutive days of warm muggy rain. The plastic tends to give the suet some protection from the wet and so I’ve found that the suet feeders with the plastic are less likely to mold.

I hadn’t seen a starling in the yard for almost a year, but with our east coast blizzard this past week, they suddenly arrived. I had gotten a few more suet cage feeders since last winter and hadn’t starling-proofed them, so the starlings quickly settled in on these. So yesterday I went to my local bird store (Mother Natures) and purchased several hooked chains (similar to the Homestead 33″ Bird Feeder Chain). I’ve been using them to dangle the remaining suet feeders with the plastic left on them.

Suet and Nut Block Feeders and Hanging Platform Bird Feeder on Baffled Pole
Suet and Nut Block Feeders and Hanging Platform Bird Feeder on Baffled Pole

I have several of regular-sized suet feeders (like the C&S EZ Fill Suet Basket) and two extra-large ones (like the Pine Tree 1451 Wire Feeder for Large Cake). Right now I’m putting purchased suet blocks in the regular-sized cage feeders. I have suet in one of the larger suet cages and a large nut block in the other. These two I wanted to hang from the arm of a bird feeding pole. It was a little tricky to figure out how to dangle these two large feeders from the same arm and still keep them positioned so that the starlings wouldn’t be able to settle on them.

Large Suet and Nut Block Cage Bird Feeders Dangling From a Baffled Pole
Large Suet and Nut Block Cage Bird Feeders Dangling From a Baffled Pole

My solution was to use flexible wire that I had in my craft stash to wire the wide edge of one feeder to a wide edge of another (as shown in the picture above.) Then I used chain and a hook to dangle them from the pole arm so that they hang in a kind of V-shape. (I had to fiddle with the hook placement until I got the right spot on each cage where they would hang the way I wanted them.) I kept the larger plastic packaging in these feeders too.

You might wonder what the birds think of all this. Well, first I must admit that my tinkering may be initially annoying to the birds (assuming that birds feel annoyed.) They get used to where things are and when you move a feeder, they tend to come to the old spot and look for it. If you haven’t moved it far though, they’ll usually find it quickly.

Suet Feeder Plastic Excavated by Male Downy Woodpecker
Suet Feeder Plastic Excavated by Male Downy Woodpecker

I’ve watched birds come to the plastic protected cages for the first time and they will usually first try to get to the suet from the top or sides. Most figure out that the bottom is accessible within about thirty seconds. The only time I’ve seen it take longer was a male Downy Woodpecker who was determined to get to the suet from the side regardless of the plastic in between. Being a woodpecker and used to pecking holes in things, he kept pounding on the side for a while before trying the bottom. Even now, I occasionally need to swap out the plastic if the sides get too ragged. (See the photo above.)

You might wonder too whether any of this is a deterrent to squirrels. Mostly not. Squirrels are very acrobatic and are willing to dangle. It’s possible that if the chain the feeder dangles from is long enough, it might thwart them. But in my experience, the only suet that has been completely free of squirrels is in the suet cage that dangles from the baffled pole arm. The squirrels haven’t figured out how to get up there . . . yet! Never bet against a squirrel that wants to eat!

2019 Update: The upside down suet in the plastic worked well for me for quite awhile. Eventually I decided to formalize things and switched up to using Birds Choice Upside Down Suet Feeders. These are excellent once birds figure them out. They keep the suet clean and dry and slow the starlings way down. Put them on a baffled pole and the squirrels can’t get them either.


Like this blog? Use the link at the bottom of the (full site) page to subscribe by email so you’ll never miss a post!

I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, “an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to” If you use an affiliate link on my site to go to Amazon and make a purchase within 24 hours, it helps me out because I earn a small fee which helps offset blog related costs. I only use these links for products I’ve used myself unless specifically noted otherwise.

4 thoughts on “Starling Proofing the Suet

  1. I have an upside down feeder that is supposed to defer starlings. I put it up specifically for woodpeckers. It went for days untouched by any of the birds. The moment I put it next to the right-side up caged suet, a pack of starlings descended on it, and devoured it. They couldn’t cling to the feeder but they flapped their wings to stay aloft, and finished all of the suet in a matter of hours. I will never use an upside down feeder again for woodpeckers. The only bird that got anything was the starling. I cannot understand how yours worked.
    baffled in Ohio (

    1. Hi D, I feel your pain. It is SOOO frustrating to be putting out seed or suet for certain birds and then have a flock of completely different birds take over. Starlings can be really tenacious about suet too.

      In my yard, it took the woodpeckers a while to learn to use the upside down feeders. Now they use them regularly. Downy and Red-Bellied Woodpeckers as well as Tufted Titmouses, Carolina Chickadees and Carolina Wrens can all cling to the upside down feeders for long periods of time to get the suet and they all come multiple times each day. Birds watch each other get food and learn strategies from each other. So other birds will try using the upside down suet feeders too. Like you’ve observed in your yard, they can’t cling like the woodpeckers but they can flap long enough to get some suet in short bursts of time. They will also hang around on the ground under a suet feeder to pick up scraps other birds have dropped from the feeder. I’ve seen Blue Jays, Eastern Starlings and Common Grackles all do it, especially this time of year when they are probably feeding their young. When it is only a few birds, this isn’t a huge problem because, since they can only hang for short periods of time, they don’t tend to dominate the feeder. But it sounds like you got a bunch all at once and that is a different story. If they were all taking turns, then even if each one was only using it for a few minutes, that would be enough to clean out the feeder.

      Do you typically see big groups of Starlings? If the flock is unusual, you might try putting the suet feeder away for a week or so and see if the Starlings move on. Then try putting it out again and give the woodpeckers another shot at it. You might cut the suet cake into halves or quarters and just put a little in at first to see who comes to eat if you don’t want to risk another whole cake getting devoured by the Starlings.

      Good luck!

  2. Thank goodness I found this. I’m having a Hell of a time w/gangs of Grackles. Yup, bullies all. But this sounds like it Would work for me since I’ve watched almost all of my birds generally feed off my 4 suet stations upside-down anyway. Only the bluejays & grackles seem to enjoy getting some from the top.
    And for anyone who keeps track (I only do for my locals), I’m on the MI/IN border & am regularly visited by Bluebirds, Grackles, tits, chickadees, downy & short tail woodies, flickers, red-breasted woody, robins, Massive juncos, house, golden, purple finches, emerald-throats, red-tailed hawk, short-eared owl, nuthatches, Gorgeous cardinals. Weird, no sparrows. And occasionally a crow will kill one of the smaller species. AND Finally had that neighborhood Pileated woodpecker stop by for a half hour. Guess I had the right kind of dead tree. Thanks.

    1. Hi Kimberlee, Definitely give this a try. It slows the annoying birds way down. Most of the birds people generally like to feed suet to (the woodpeckers, nuthatches, wrens, etc.) are totally fine with dangling. Over time some of the other birds will start to learn to dangle to grab some suet or they might hang around underneath the feeder when the woodpeckers are using it to get fallen scraps, but the annoying birds typically can’t stay on the feeder long so they can’t dominate the feeder in the same way. And anyway, since you are using the suet packaging, it won’t cost anything to try it which is always a plus! These days I’ve switched to Birds Choice Upside Down Suet Feeders which work pretty much the same way but look a bit nicer but the plastic method should help you out a lot I think.

      You have a wonderful mix of birds in your yard. We get some of those down here in Maryland but you have some cool visitors we don’t see. And I’m totally envious of your Pileated visitor! I’ve only seen those in parks, never in my yard. : )


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.